How to Know Whether You Have a Good Feed Conversion Ratio — and How to Use it to Drive More Genetic Progress
Ask 10 beef producers what a good feed conversion ratio is, and you’ll likely get 10 different answers.
But depending on those producers’ goals, the animals’ characteristics, and a few other factors, every answer might be partially correct. “It depends” is the only response that will always be right.
That’s why recognizing the full Feed Conversion Ratio (FCR) picture, not just asking “what’s a good FCR for my herd?”, is so important.
Understanding exactly how FCR is calculated, how it can vary within systems, and how to effectively leverage the metric for better decision-making can give your operation an important boost.
How a good feed conversion ratio can vary across cattle systems
A feed conversion ratio is one metric for evaluating feed efficiency. It’s an animal or herd’s total feed consumed divided by the total weight gained.
FCR data will look very different depending on what type of cattle system you’re measuring.
For example, a stocker steer may have a better FCR than an open cow, while an open cow may outperform a pregnant cow. That’s why it’s important to compare like with like when evaluating FCR data to ensure cattle are being evaluated fairly.
What you’re feeding animals might also make a difference. Feedlot animals’ FCR won’t be the same as those fed on pasture.
Age and production stage also influence FCR, whether cattle are freshly weaned, in their peak growth period, or nearing finishing.
These answers will heavily influence what a “good” FCR might be at your operation.
How you can use FCR to evaluate your herd and make more genetic progress
Feed conversion ratio is a relatively easy metric to calculate. But since it’s so simple, it doesn’t always incorporate every piece of context to fully understand an animal’s feed efficiency. To make the strongest genetic decisions, it’s best to evaluate FCR with other efficiency metrics, like Dry Matter Intake (DMI) and Residual Feed Intake (RFI).
FCR is best used as a tool to compare animals within a specific cohort. One animal may have a strong FCR, but their overall gain metrics aren’t great. If you’re sitting around holding an animal in a feedlot for 200 days solely because they had a good FCR — but it took them a long time to achieve their target weight — that’s an indication of a missed opportunity.
It’s also helpful to think about FCR alongside other indices, such as $B (Beef Value) or $M (Maternal Weaned Calf Value) that cattle associations have established.
Benchmarking your herd or individual animals’ FCR data with similar operations can also be useful. But be careful here: benchmarking data is most valuable when you compare it to your neighbors who have similar resources and goals.
You don’t want to benchmark yourself against operators in different parts of the country or that do different things. An east coast cow-calf operation doesn’t need to benchmark their FCR data to a seedstock producer in the desert, for instance.
The importance of individual animal data over herd or pen averages
Understanding your herd’s average efficiency (using FCR) at a macro level can be useful.
But you accelerate your decision-making capacity when you can drill down to the individual level.
There will always be a bell curve of performance: about 15% top performers, 15% at the bottom, and the rest in the middle. Identifying elite animals in that top range, then ensuring you select for and advance those quality genetics, is how you create generational improvement within a herd.
Individual-level evaluation is also helpful when you evaluate potential semen purchases, or a bull you’re bringing into the herd. You need to find genetics that have been individually measured so you know they weren’t on the bottom of that bell curve.
Relying on pen or herd-level metrics could land you with genetics from that bottom 15%. And that slip-up could set your herd back a generation.
How Vytelle SENSE™ empowers a better data foundation to understand your herd’s FCR
Vytelle SENSE is a platform to help producers measure their herd’s feed efficiency so they can save money, identify their highest performers, and build more efficient (and profitable) herds.
Vytelle collects the highest quality data, then presents it in a few different reports for producers to evaluate. For example, a report may chart out a specific cohort group so a producer can rank each animal according to FCR and other metrics. They can easily see which animals are in the right quadrant (those who had good gain, and did so efficiently) vs animals who may have had a lot of gain but did it inefficiently.
With this data, you can make more confident decisions about which animals are doing the most with the least amount of resources, then select for and progress those genetics in your herd. Using in-pen weighing systems, Vytelle can also set alerts for when animals’ FCR starts to drop or plateau so you can make more informed (and faster) management decisions.
Reach out to the Vytelle team to get a quote for how you can integrate SENSE technology and build a more efficient operation.